The Stacked Pickle, Carmel, Indiana

The Stacked Pickle is one of yet another sports bars in the Carmel area.  There seem to be 1,000 of these around, some really great, some so so, some really terrible.

I visited The Stacked Pickle on the advice of a friend who had been there and was happy with his experience, so I decided to give them a try.

We were greeted promptly by a friendly hostess, and our waitress was cordial without being TOO friendly.  The manager walked over and introduced himself, having never seen us in there before, and that was certainly a nice touch.

This restaurant gets extra points for cleanliness…it was absolutely pristine inside.  It also gets high marks for being spacious and well laid out.  I have a low tolerance for sports bars that are so cramped and noisy I can barely hear myself think, but this place was spacious, roomy, and a very pleasant atmosphere indeed.

Of course, I was only here to review their tenderloin, and the manager told me they sell a lot of them.  How would it stack up?

The tenderloin comes with fries for $6.95…a very reasonable price indeed!  It comes on a kaiser roll that was very nicely toasted, and it’s a quite large sandwich.  The meat is not pounded paper thin rather, it reminded me of a nice, thick pork chop.  Very, very tasty, tender, moist, and juicy.  I wish ALL breaded tenderloins had this quality of meat.

The breading appears to be something like tempura batter.  It was nice and crunchy, a bit thicker than some other restaurants bread their tenderloins, but with the thickness of the cut of meat it worked very well indeed.  The breading didn’t get soggy at all, and overall this is certainly an above average Breaded Tenderloin sandwich.

Really, only a couple of minor issues keeps this from being a 5 out of 5, my highest rating.  First, I asked for onion on my sandwich, and, as you can see, I got two, lonely little onion rings, and they appeared to be a bit wilted at that.  Second, it’s not quite what we call a traditional breaded tenderloin.  All that aside, I’m going to give it a 4.3 on a scale of 1-5 bites.  Well above average, and it’s certainly worth the money.  It was a filling, satisfying meal at a reasonable price.  I left happy.

I MUST say a word about the french fries.  They’re beer battered, and simply fabulous.  Don’t miss the fries if you visit!

The Stacked Pickle is located at 12545 N Meridian (across from Meijer) in Carmel, Indiana.  You can visit their website here.  It is an all ages, 21 and over restaurant, untill 10 PM, then it’s 21 and over only.


3 thoughts on “The Stacked Pickle, Carmel, Indiana

  1. Thanks for the review…we tried the Stacked Pickle today and it was yummy! You are absolutely right about the fries – great! They now have onion rings. Incredible! They put cracked pepper in the batter and a really crispy coating. I had the tenderloin – delicious 🙂 It is nice to discover a new place that is actually really good!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s