Recently, a commenter on here suggested, that, since I’ve completed my first 100 reviews, I post my top 5 of the first 100. I’m going to cut it down even further, and post my top three.
I’m going to qualify this a bit. I believe these are the top 3 tenderloins in Indy (out of those I’ve tried, anyway). These all have 5/5 ratings, but they’re all a bit different. In addition to the tenderloins being different, all three venues are different, so I’m going to talk a bit about each specific venue.
Please note that I am putting these in alphabetical order. They’re ALL outstanding and I really can’t rate one over the other.
The Aristocrat. For those who don’t know, the Aristocrat recently suffered a devastating fire, but they are rebuilding and are slated to re-open in the spring of 2012.
The Aristocrat has long been one of my favorite restaurants in Indy. It’s a nice, non smoking pub that features live music on an irregular basis. There is bar and dining room seating, as well as a delightful atmosphere. Service has always been outstanding, and I can honestly say I’ve never even been the slight bit disappointed there. These folks have been around for years, and they know what they’re doing. If you’re not a tenderloin fan, there are plenty of other options on the menu, from burgers to steaks to salads and just about everything in between. They also have a Sunday Brunch that folks rave about, but I’ve not tried it myself.
You can see the original Aristocrat review at:
C. R. Heroe’s Family Pub. I’m not sure, but I believe C R Heroe’s was one of the first to bring the “family pub” concept to the area, and it’s served them well. No matter what age you are, you can have fun and a great meal here. The restaurant is nicely decorated, the staff is friendly, and the portions are ample. A couple of things to try: the garlic mayo…I wasn’t so sure about it, but, WOW…that is some good stuff. Also, the Italian Beef sandwich is, according to those in the know, the best around. It’s also a very good place to watch a ball game, and they always have something special going on there.
You can see the original C. R. Heroe’s review at:
Jimmy B’s. Jimmy B’s is the place where it all started. If you’re looking for classy dining, let me tell you right off…this isn’t the place for you. But if you’re looking for the quintessential neighborhood bar…with good food….you won’t go wrong here. It’s 21 and over, and smoker friendly, but if you go during off peak hours you’ll be OK. The tenderloin has to be eaten to be believed, the burgers are quite good, and Holly raves about the chicken quesadillas. The waffle fries are perfect, and it’s one of the best places in town to people watch.
You can see the latest original Jimmy B’s review at:
And, there you have it – my top 3 out of my first 100 reviews. Stay tuned for number 101!