Alibi’s Bar and Grill,  Indianapolis 

​Alibi’s bar and grill is a place that we were vaguely aware of…matter of fact, we’d had dinner here several years ago, but it’s in an area that we don’t often find ourselves in so it tends to fly under our radar. We were taking care of some personal business in this part of town, and decided to try their tenderloin.

Located in Shadeland Station, Alibi’s has been around since 1986 and their website proudly proclaims they feature “hand crafted, American cooking”. As an added bonus, they’re non-smoking and all ages, a huge plus in my book!

Situated in the Shadeland Station shopping center, it’s a very large place! Nicely decorated in dark wood, there are TV’s around tuned to sports, but not so many to be overwhelming, and the sound is down low enough that you can enjoy a nice meal without being overwhelmed by constant noise.

Of course, I was there to try the hand cut and hand breaded tenderloin. It’s offered breaded or grilled, and comes with your choice of side for a bit over 9 bucks.

So, how was it? It was very good indeed! It’s big, but I wouldn’t call it huge (at least by breaded tenderloin standards). It’s pounded out to a nice size, but it’s not paper thin. There’s a very nice texture in this sandwich…the crunch of the breading and the firmness of the meat. The meat was tender, yet firm, and had a very good flavor. I REALLY liked the breading, but feel it could have used some more seasoning…perhaps something as simple as a bit more pepper…to really make this sandwich shine. It was served dressed as I requested, the bun was nicely buttered and toasted. It was a quite satisfying sandwich! I’m going to give it a 4 out of 5 bites…well above average and worth your time. On a side note, I REALLY liked their French fries!

For her lunch, Holly chose the white Stromboli. Alibi’s white Stromboli consists of a grilled chicken breast, smoked Gouda cheese, onions, pepperoni, and banana peppers, topped with a white sauce that seemed to be a simple creamy Italian dressing. It is served lightly toasted on a soft hoagie. The manager visited our table and said she likes to request this sandwich toasted longer to enhance the crunchy texture of the bread. Holly said she would definitely get this sandwich again. And when she does, she will take the manager’s recommendation and ask for it to be toasted a little longer.

Alibi’s is located in the Shadeland Station shopping center, 7381 N Shadeland Avenue in Indianapolis. You can find them online at http://www.alibisgrill.com and they also have a Facebook page. 

Storie’s restaurant, Greensburg Indiana

wp-image-1650506772jpg.jpg

I’d heard good things about Storie’s restaurant in Greensburg, Indiana but the timing for us to make a stop never worked out until this weekend, when we met our friends Deb, Tony, and Aiden for dinner there on Friday night.

Here’s an interesting (to me, at least), side note to this review.  One of my grandmothers was named Storey.  However, the original spelling of the name was Storie.  The story goes that one of the Stories got into legal trouble…he was a horse thief, I’m told, and the family changed the spelling to Storey because they didn’t want to be associated with that side of the family.  But, I digress….which happens pretty often.

Storie’s is located on the courthouse square in Greensburg, Indiana.  It seems like they’ve been around forever.  It’s larger than it appears on the outside, with ample dining area and a nice, long, lunch counter that reminds me of the old Woolworth lunch counters.  Cozy, warm, and friendly, it’s everything a small town restaurant should be.

Honestly, I didn’t look over the menu very closely….I already had made up my mind that I was going to try the tenderloin.  My impression is that they are heavy on the comfort food, though.

I asked our waitress about the breaded tenderloin, and she told me each one was hand breaded to order, and that was enough for me!

wp-image-129164216jpg.jpg

It’s a VERY good sandwich.  Matter of fact, it’s as good as any I’ve had in my travels.  It’s a nice size without being overwhelming, and it hits the mark of being not too thin or not too thick…just about perfect.  The breading itself had just enough seasoning to compliment without overwhelming the taste of the meat, and it stayed crunchy throughout the life of the sandwich.  The meat itself was moist and tender.  There’s no doubt about it, this one is a 5 out of 5 bites.  It goes in my personal hall of fame.

I chose a “platter”, which included fries and slaw.  The fries were crinkle cut, my favorite, and tasty but not outstanding.  The taste of the slaw was fine, but it seemed to have a lot of dressing, and the cabbage was diced very fine the combination of those two things made it less than stellar for my preference.  I neglected to get the exact price, but the sandwich, fries and slaw came in the neighborhood of $8.50 or so, well worth the price.

For her dinner, Holly got the pulled pork sandwich platter with slaw, and for a small upcharge substituted fries for oven roasted potatoes.  The pork was swimming in sauce, which she says isnt her preference.  The potatoes were hot and crisp, but average on the flavor.

Storie’s restaurant is located at 109 E Main Street in Greensburg, Indiana.  You can find them online at http://www.storiesrestaurant.com/

Metro Diner, Indianapolis

metro-outside

 

I’ve been excited to try the Metro Diner on the north side of Indy ever since they opened a few months ago.  We actually tried to go this past Sunday, but the line was stretched out the door to get in, and we were on a bit of a schedule, so we decided to drop in last night for an early dinner.

The Metro Diner is a throwback to the diners of the 50s, with a bit of an upscale twist.  There’s a small counter with a half dozen or so stools in front of the grill, and a large dining area with tables and booths.  It’s a small chain, and their emphasis is on comfort food, as evidenced by some of their menu items…meatloaf, pot roast, and the like.

We arrived about 415 PM and again, I realized how very important a first impression is when trying a new restaurant.  There was a host at the host station, and we stopped and there was a moment of awkwardness…he wasn’t especially welcoming.  And, honestly, we both found him a little aloof and off putting, which wasn’t a good sign for a place that stakes its reputation on comfort food and being comfortable.  However, we were seated and our server, LaChelle, proved herself to be capable, personable, and helpful in explaining the menu.

I already knew what I wanted…the Big Bern Fried Pork sandwich, which is their version of a Breaded Pork Tenderloin.

img_20161020_164315324.jpg

I knew going in that this wasn’t a traditional Hoosier Pork Tenderloin.  For starters, it’s served on grilled Italian bread.  And it’s topped with provel cheese, wilted spinach, caramelized red onions, bacon, fried jalapenos, tomatoes, and garlic aioli.  I decided to be adventurous and get it exactly as it’s served.  Being a traditionalist when it comes to food (and most other areas of my life) this is a bit of a stretch for me, but, what’s life without a little adventure thrown in?

As is my tradition, I cut a corner of the meat off and sampled it, and my first thought was that it was just a little bland.  However, once I tried it all together, it was absolutely stellar.  All those flavors and textures meld together to make it a VERY good sandwich.  They’ve obviously done their homework on this one, every flavor and texture complimented the other one, without one overwhelming another on the sandwich.

Since it’s not a traditional sandwich, I’m not going to rate it on my traditional 1-5 scale…I’m going to rate it on the “would I order it again” scale, and the answer is, yes, absolutely.  I REALLY liked it and would not hesitate to order it again.

This is an added bonus….it’s so big, I couldn’t finish it all, which is a rarity for me.  I’ve got half left over for lunch today!

For my side order, I chose onion rings, and they were very good also.  I won’t go so far as to say they’re the best in town, but they’re well above average and I wouldn’t hesitate to order those again, either.

For her dinner, Holly chose the grilled fish wrap with homemade potato chips, and she reports them to be outstanding. The chips are extra crispy – like a kettle cooked chip – and simply seasoned.

We splurged for dessert this night.  I had the strawberry shortcake and it was awesome, and Holly chose the Key Lime Pie.  Being that the original Metro Diner is in Jacksonville, rest assured that their homemade Key Lime pie is the real deal – and it is delicious!
The Metro Diner is located at 3954 E 82nd street in Indianapolis.  Their website is www.metrodiner.com and you can also find them on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.

North End BBQ and Moonshine, Indianapolis (Nora)

north-end-front

 

North End BBQ is a relatively new restaurant on the north side of Indy, known as Nora.

Situated in a small strip mall, it’s divided into 3 areas, a bar, a family dining area, and a VERY nice outside patio.

As a BBQ restaurant, BBQ is their main emphasis.  However, there are a few other things on the menu…a burger two, quite a few appetizers, and a few salads.

We were planning to meet some friends for dinner, so I brought up their online menu and saw a breaded tenderloin, and knew I had to try it.

We arrived about 5PM and our capable server, Ellen, told us it was a lunch menu item only.  I expressed my disappointment, because I had come to try it, and she went back to the kitchen and they were glad to make it for me.

north-end-loin

This is a VERY good tenderloin.  It’s just a tad thinner than I normally prefer, but in this case it worked, and it worked well.  The breading was nice and light, and there was a nice texture difference between the crispness of the breading and the tenderness of the meat.  That’s one reason I’m a fan of thicker tenderloins, the differences in texture, but that wasn’t an issue with this one.

The breading was seasoned nicely, just enough to add a little flavor without overwhelming the flavor.  Personally, I would have preferred a little more seasoning, but that’s just a matter of personal preference.

The meat was not quite as tender as some I’ve had, still it was well above average and nice and moist.

It was served dressed as I requested.  It’s a VERY good sandwich.  I don’t think it is quite one of the very best in Indy, so I’m going to give it a 4.5 out of 5.  Very, very good indeed and I highly recommend it.

For my side, I got their fries, which are paired with smoked bone marrow butter and jalapenos, and these are simply outstanding. I do believe they’re my favorite fries in town, but they’re not quite traditional.  Still, I HIGHLY recommend trying these.

For her dinner, Holly had the Carolina pulled pork.  It comes with two sides – and she chose the collard greens and cornbread, which is served with maple bourbon butter.  She reported the pulled pork to be tender and flavorful.  She said It was fun to try the variety of sauces that North End provides!

North End BBQ is located on 86th street, in the Nora Plaza.  You can find them online at www.thenorthendbbq.com  and they also have a Facebook page.

Broad Ripple Tavern, Indianapolis

broad-ripple-tavern

 

We don’t get to Broad Ripple as often as we probably should. It’s a very cool part of town, and accouple of our favorite restaurants ARE there….Shalimar Indian Restaurant and The Aristocrat. Still, it’s not a place we find as a destination very often.

We were having a meeting last week, and it was at the Broad Ripple Tavern, a place I’d vaguely heard of but had never been to.

Broad Ripple Tavern seems a little more “mature” than some of the other bars in the area.
Perhaps it was because we were there on a weeknight, but it seemed that the clientele was a little older. A nice bar in the front, it opens into a huge back room that has some pool tables, a very  nice stage, and a ton of TVs for watching sports or whatever suits your fancy.

Since we were having a meeting, it was a good way to judge how our server handled this. Our sever, Nicole, was a pro. She gave us ample opportunity to handle our business without
pressuring us to order or pay, yet made sure our drinks were filled and everything was taken care of in a timely manner. Well done.

The menu isn’t the largest I’ve seen…and features pretty typical pub fare: burgers, sandwiches, appetizers, and the like. I asked our server about the breaded tenderloin, and she assured me that it was hand breaded in house. On top of that, everything breaded item they serve…chicken fingers, etc, is hand breaded in a buttermilk based breading, so I was sold.

brt-loin

So, how was it? It was VERY good. As a matter of fact, I believe it stacks up well against any
tenderloin in town. The breading was quite tasty, nice and crisp, with just enough seasoning to compliment the flavor without overwhelming it. The meat itself was nice and tender. The bun was nicely toasted and the sandwich was dressed as I requested it. In addition, I believe the sandwich was just the right size…a nice, satisfying meal without being overwhelming. I give it a 5 out of 5, no doubt about it in my eyes.

For her dinner, Holly ordered the pulled pork sliders and tavern fries. She reports: “The BBQ was a little sweeter than I prefer. I’ll be sure to ask for hot sauce the next time!” When we asked what tavern fries were, we were told they were seasoned waffle fries. They actually came out at seasoned matchstick fries – but all is well, because they were very tasty!

Broad Ripple Tavern is located at 745 Broad Ripple Avenue in Indy. Their website is
http://www.broadrippletavern.com and they also are on twitter and facebook.

The Willard, Franklin, Indiana

willard-front

The Williard is one of those regionally famous places I’d never had a chance to try.

Located in an old hotel in historic Franklin, Indiana, it’s one of those places that fairly screams history.  Beautiful old woodwork, tile floors, a wonderful wooden staircase (that kind of leads to nowhere), it’s worth a visit just to wander around.  Yes, it’s a bit run down and worn around the edges, but that’s part of its charm.

It appears to be famous for 3 things…pizza, tenderloins, and wings.  They were one of the contestants at the Tenderloin Throwdown in Greensburg, Indiana earlier this year, so I’d had a chance to sample their tenderloin, but not to enjoy the whole experience.

We arrived at about 5PM on Saturday evening, and since it was such a lovely evening, we chose to sit outside.  If the weather is nice, it’s a great place to sit, dine, and watch the world go by.

The menu features pizza and wings above all else, it seems, but there is quite a few other choices on the menu.  Of course, I was there to try the breaded tenderloin.

willard-loin

This is really one fine tenderloin.  The meat is fresh, moist, and tender, and the flavor is spot on. It’s certainly one of the best I’ve had in a while.

The breading is also VERY tasty.  It’s quite tasty, and REALLY crisp.  The breading has a nice peppery taste to it.  I’m a fan of that peppery taste, so it rates very high on my list, but I realize that’s a matter of personal preference, so be aware if you are not a fan of pepper, this might not be one of your favorites,  It was, however, one of mine.  It gave a nice kick to the sandwich.

The sandwich was served dressed as I requested, with nice attention to detail.  In my book, this is certainly a 5 bite tenderloin. I would not hesitate to order it again.

For my side, I chose fries.  They were good, but fell short of outstanding.

For her dinner, Holly chose the sweet chili wings and a dinner salad.  For wings with “chili” in the name, they were quite mild – in fact, the flavor was rather bland.  Holly reports the wings themselves were meaty and tender, but that she would try a different sauce next time – one with more flavor.

In reading other reviews of The Williard, it appears they have some ongoing service issues, and our visit was no different.  It took over an hour to get our food, and we saw other parties who came in after us order, get their meal, and be finished before we got ours.  The food was outstanding and makes me want to return, but the service?  Not so much.
The Williard is located at 99 N Main Street in Franklin.  It appears their webpage is inactive, but they do have a Facebook page.

Peppy Grill, Indianapolis (Fountain Square)

peppy-sign

There are a few places in Indianapolis that have attained legendary status, and I believe that Peppy’s Grill is one of those.

Located in the Fountain Square area, it’s been an institution for as long as I can remember.  Back in the 80’s, I occasionally had to make an overnight run to Indianapolis for work, and Peppy’s was our go to place for a 3AM breakfast.  As good as the food was, the people watching at that time of the morning was just as good…perhaps better.

Peppy’s, and places like it, are forerunners of places like Denny’s and Waffle House  (two of my favorites), 24 hour a day diner type restaurants that serve good, cheap food,  None of it is gourmet, none of it is especially healthy, but, boy, is it satisfying.

Peppy’s has the magic that a diner SHOULD have.  I’d a little bit run down, it shows some wear and tear, but it also shows a special kind of magic  you can’t find anywhere else.

The menu is pretty basic…hamburgers and cheeseburgers (called cheeseburgs), grilled ham and cheese, a ribeye steak, biscuits and gravy, and such.  It also offers both a grilled and a breaded tenderloin.

I rather suspected this might be a fritter, but I decided to chance it anyway.  After all, we were at Peppy’s and I wanted the full experience.

peppy-loin

I’m happy to report that it’s not a fritter after all, but a true tenderloin.  It’s a solid piece of meat.

It’s pounded out thinner than I prefer, but the flavor was pretty good…not outstanding, but pretty tasty.  The meat I found to be just a bit on the dry side, but the breading was nice and crispy and stayed that way through the life of the sandwich.  The sandwich was nicely seasoned, and served dressed as I requested.

This isn’t a great sandwich, but it’s not bad either.  I’m going to give it a 3.5 out of 5 bites.  Although when we return I’ll likely order a cheeseburg, this certainly is a better sandwich than what a lot of restaurants pass off as a breaded tenderloin.

For my side, I chose the sour cream fries.   These are more like potato wedges with some sort of sour cream sauce on the side, and boy are they tasty!  I highly recommend these.
Holly chose the classic cheeseburg and sour cream fries.  The patty is preformed and a little on the dry side, but for the price, you can’t go wrong with this meal!

Peppy’s Grill is located at 1004 Virginia Avenue in Indy.  They don’t have Facebook, Twitter, or a website…which is part of their charm.